I have known a vast quantity of nonsense talked about bad men

Hear the wise and piercing words of Charles Dickens, who declared: “I have known a vast quantity of nonsense talked about bad men not looking you in the face. Don’t trust that conventional idea. Dishonesty will stare honesty out of countenance any day in the week, if there is anything to be got by it.” In these words lies a warning against the easy judgments of appearances. Too often, the world believes that liars avert their eyes, that villains tremble before the gaze of the righteous. But Dickens, keen observer of men and their follies, reveals the deeper truth: the shameless will often meet your eye with boldness, for deceit wears the mask of confidence, and evil has no trouble clothing itself in charm when gain is at stake.

The origin of this insight comes from Dickens’ long life among the crooked and the noble alike. In the alleys of London, he saw swindlers, cheats, and hypocrites who could smile sweetly while robbing the poor, who could meet a man’s gaze while plotting his ruin. He knew that the true mark of dishonesty is not in the eyes, but in the heart and in the actions. Appearances deceive; boldness is no proof of truth, and timidity no proof of guilt. Thus Dickens warns us: do not trust in outward signs alone, for dishonesty can mimic the very posture of virtue.

History, too, bears witness. Consider the tale of Bernie Madoff, who for decades looked investors in the eye, speaking with confidence, charm, and apparent sincerity, while orchestrating one of the greatest financial frauds of modern times. His composure was so steady that even seasoned men of finance were deceived. Did his eyes betray him? No. His gaze was steady, his voice persuasive. Only his deeds, when revealed, unmasked the truth. This is Dickens’ point brought to life: evil need not avert its face, for it will often stare straight into yours with calm assurance.

And yet, many still cling to the myth that guilt always shows itself in fear. But guilt is not always shy; sometimes it is brazen. The tyrant who enslaves others may speak of freedom while looking into the camera; the corrupt leader may swear honesty while meeting the gaze of millions. Deceit is often bold, for boldness itself is a weapon. Dickens teaches us not to be seduced by this weapon, but to learn discernment that pierces beyond appearances.

What, then, should one trust, if not the gaze? Trust the actions, trust the patterns, trust the harmony—or the discord—between words and deeds. A man’s eyes may lie, but his consistent choices will reveal the truth. As the ancient proverb says: “By their fruits you shall know them.” To place faith in mere appearances is folly; to test words by deeds is wisdom.

The lesson for our lives is both urgent and clear: do not be dazzled by confidence, nor dismissive of the quiet or uncertain. The liar may cloak himself in courage, while the honest man trembles from shyness or fear. Seek always to look deeper—at consistency, at history, at integrity proven over time. This vigilance guards the heart from the charm of dishonesty.

Therefore, remember Dickens’ counsel: dishonesty will stare honesty out of countenance if there is gain to be won. Do not be fooled by bold eyes or steady voices. Look instead at truth revealed through action, at character proven by endurance. In this way, you will not be deceived by the masks of confidence, but will walk in the deeper wisdom that sees beyond appearances, discerning the true face of virtue and the hidden mask of vice.

–––