I work on words, mostly, toward them being poetry or short
I work on words, mostly, toward them being poetry or short stories, and then some of those become songs. They all find their place in the world, but they all start off in the same place. I'm always painting and drawing as well, and it's an ongoing creative assignment.
P. J. Harvey, a voice both fierce and haunting, once confessed: “I work on words, mostly, toward them being poetry or short stories, and then some of those become songs. They all find their place in the world, but they all start off in the same place. I’m always painting and drawing as well, and it’s an ongoing creative assignment.” These words are not merely a description of her craft, but a testimony to the eternal nature of creativity itself: that all art begins as a seed, and from that seed, many branches grow.
The meaning is luminous: the act of creation is not rigid, but fluid. A single phrase may be born as poetry, then travel into a story, and later transform into the lyrics of a song. A sketch on paper may evolve into a painting, or remain only as a memory, yet still it carries truth. Harvey reminds us that art is not confined to form—it is a current of energy, flowing through words, sound, and image, taking the shape it must in order to live.
The ancients knew this well. The poet Hesiod sang of the Muses, daughters of memory, who inspired not only poetry, but song, dance, and history itself. To the Greeks, creativity was one river with many streams. The bard might sing one day, inscribe another, or carve in stone on another. Harvey’s practice is an echo of that ancient truth: that all artistic acts are siblings, sharing a common root. The place in the world each piece finds is determined not by the artist’s will alone, but by the life of the work itself.
History too offers its witness. Leonardo da Vinci wrote in notebooks, drew endlessly, painted masterpieces, and sketched inventions that would not be built for centuries. To him, the work of art and the work of science, the sketch and the story, were not separate tasks but one great creative assignment—to explore, to give form, to discover. The genius of Leonardo was not in limiting himself, but in allowing creation to take any form it wished. P. J. Harvey’s words live in that same lineage, a reminder that art must remain expansive and unchained.
Her wisdom also speaks to the persistence of creation. By calling it an ongoing assignment, she affirms that art is never truly finished. A poem may lie dormant, only to become a lyric years later. A half-forgotten drawing may inspire a new song. Creativity is not a single act, but a lifelong conversation with the self, with the world, with the mysteries that stir beneath the surface of life. To create is to accept that the task is never done, and that this is not a burden, but a gift.
The lesson is clear: do not confine your creativity to one form or fear that your art must be perfect before it lives. Begin with words, with sketches, with fragments. Let them grow into what they must be—poetry, stories, music, or paintings. Trust that each act will find its place in the world. The artist is not the dictator of form, but the midwife of expression. Your only duty is to keep working, to keep shaping, to keep creating.
Practical action follows naturally. Keep a notebook where words may rest until they become something greater. Keep sketches, melodies, fragments, for they may return in another form. Do not despise the beginnings, for they are sacred. Approach your creativity as an assignment not from the world, but from your own soul. And know this: the task never ends, but neither does the joy.
Thus, remember the wisdom of P. J. Harvey: all art begins in the same place, but each work finds its own path, its own form, its own place in the world. To live as a creator is to honor this flow, to surrender to the great current of imagination. It is to labor not for applause, but for the deep, sustaining joy of bringing forth what was hidden, and setting it free.
NLTran Ngoc Lan
I’m intrigued by Harvey’s approach where her poems and short stories eventually evolve into songs, suggesting that each piece finds its ‘place’ in the world. Is this a reminder that creativity doesn’t always need to be forced into one category, but rather allowed to take shape in its own time and form? How important is it to remain open to how an idea can evolve, especially when it can be transformed into something entirely different along the way?
KL6A2 THCS Nghia Tan Vu Phuong Khanh Linh
Harvey seems to suggest that creativity is not about following one fixed path, but about allowing different ideas and mediums to come together. Can this approach to creativity help artists avoid feeling boxed in by specific genres or forms? How does this kind of open-ended creative process allow for more experimentation and risk-taking? Could focusing on one medium limit artistic potential, or does working across disciplines provide more freedom and room for innovation?
DCDieu Chou
Harvey’s mention of starting with words and letting them evolve into different forms, like songs, really highlights the organic nature of creativity. But does it mean that some of her works are initially incomplete until they find their place in the world? How important is it for a piece of art to have time to grow and evolve in different directions before it’s finalized? How much of her creative process is about letting the work develop naturally versus shaping it into something specific?
HKSo Huyn Kim
I love how Harvey speaks about her work as a creative assignment. Does this imply that creativity is an ongoing, never-ending process for her? How does this mindset affect her productivity and growth as an artist? Is it possible to view creativity as a continuous journey rather than something you complete, and how does that affect the work you produce? How does having multiple creative outlets, like painting and writing, influence one’s sense of self as an artist?
NTngoc tram
P. J. Harvey’s description of her creative process is fascinating, as it shows how different forms of art flow into each other. Is this an indication that creativity isn’t confined to one medium, but is a broader, more interconnected process? Does this make her approach to songwriting and poetry more fluid and open? How do you think working across multiple forms of art—like writing, painting, and drawing—enhances her creative output? Can other artists find inspiration in crossing different artistic boundaries?