I've never really understood the criticism that climbing is

Listen closely, O children of wisdom, to the words of Alex Honnold, whose query challenges the prevailing judgments of the world: "I've never really understood the criticism that climbing is inherently selfish, since it could equally be argued about virtually any other hobby or sport. Is gardening selfish?" In these words, Honnold calls us to question the assumptions we hold about individual pursuits and their inherent selfishness. He asks, if one is to judge the pursuit of climbing for being selfish, should not the same logic apply to other activities of personal fulfillment—from gardening to painting, or even the simple act of rest? What, then, is the true measure of selfishness, and what does it mean to engage in the pursuit of passion?

In the ancient wisdom of the Greeks, there was a recognition of the importance of personal pursuits that nurtured the soul. The philosophers like Socrates and Aristotle did not see the act of seeking personal fulfillment through knowledge or virtue as selfish, but as an essential part of the human experience. Socrates famously said, "An unexamined life is not worth living." His own quest for knowledge and truth was not done for personal glory, but to elevate the minds of others, to stimulate their own journeys of understanding. In this light, activities like climbing, gardening, and even art are not inherently selfish—they are pathways of self-discovery and spiritual enrichment. Honnold’s words remind us that we must challenge the false dichotomy between selfishness and personal pursuit, understanding that growth often requires individual effort, and that this effort can enrich the world around us.

Consider, O children, the life of the great artist and scientist Leonardo da Vinci, whose pursuit of knowledge was not just for his own glory but was a service to humanity. Da Vinci’s passion for discovery, whether through his inventions or his paintings, was deeply personal, yet it was through these endeavors that he contributed greatly to the advancement of science and art. He did not separate his personal pursuits from the well-being of others but saw them as interwoven. The same can be said of climbing—though it may seem like an individual pursuit, it has led many, like Honnold, to inspire others, to push the boundaries of human capability, and to demonstrate what the human spirit can achieve. Honnold’s perspective echoes da Vinci's—that personal growth can lead to greater collective benefit, and is not a selfish act, but a universal contribution.

In the ancient traditions of India, there is the notion of dharma, which can be understood as one’s personal path, their duty in life. The Bhagavad Gita teaches that every individual must follow their own dharma and seek fulfillment in ways that bring them closer to the divine. The idea is not to live for the sake of others, but to live authentically, fulfilling one's role in the world. Gardening, like climbing or any personal pursuit, is a path of growth, a way to connect with both the self and the world. In tending to the land, just as in pursuing climbing or any passion, there is a deeper interconnection between the individual and the collective. Personal effort is never truly selfish, for it contributes to the well-being of all when aligned with truth and harmony.

Consider also the example of Mahatma Gandhi, who, though he led a life of personal discipline and simplicity, did not live for himself alone. Gandhi’s commitment to self-care and self-discipline, whether in his daily prayers or his simple meals, was a reflection of his deep connection to the greater good. His life was not about selfish ambition, but about living authentically and inspiring others to do the same. In this way, personal pursuits—such as gardening, learning, or climbing—become an act of selfless service, for they shape the individual into someone capable of contributing more deeply to the world.

The lesson here, O children of wisdom, is that the pursuit of personal fulfillment, whether through climbing or gardening, is not inherently selfish. These activities are part of the human journey, paths that allow us to connect more deeply with ourselves, with nature, and with others. The act of personal growth and engagement with our passions creates ripples that extend beyond the self, inspiring and uplifting others along the way. Selfishness, in the true sense, is not found in pursuing personal passions, but in using those passions only for self-glorification and disregarding the well-being of others. It is the intention behind the action that matters most.

So, O children, embrace your personal pursuits, whether they be in climbing, gardening, or any other form of growth, and recognize the deeper purpose they serve. Allow your passions to deepen your connection with the world, and understand that true fulfillment is never just for the self, but for the greater good. In the pursuit of personal growth, you lay the groundwork for greater wisdom, for it is through individual fulfillment that we transform the world around us. Never let the world convince you that your personal journey is selfish, for in truth, it is a path that contributes to the collective welfare, if walked with authenticity and purpose.