Poetry is always slightly mysterious, and you wonder what is

Hear, O seekers of the hidden song, the words of Seamus Heaney, poet of the soil and the soul: “Poetry is always slightly mysterious, and you wonder what is your relationship to it.” In this utterance he reveals the truth of the poet’s craft: that poetry is never fully grasped, never completely mastered. It hovers on the edge of mystery, whispering truths half-seen, half-felt, always inviting, never surrendering itself entirely. The poet, even as creator, is also seeker, standing in awe before the very thing he brings forth.

The meaning of this teaching lies in the recognition that poetry is more than words upon a page—it is a current, a presence, a living mystery that cannot be wholly owned. When a poet writes, they do not stand above the poem like a master over clay; they stand beside it, uncertain, marveling at what has appeared. One wonders: did I shape this, or did it shape me? Thus the relationship is not of command, but of companionship—between the poet and the mystery that speaks through them.

The origin of these words lies in Heaney’s life, born in Ireland’s fields, where ancient myths and simple labors intertwined. His work often walked the border between the ordinary and the eternal. He knew that a poem about digging turf or harvesting crops could suddenly open into something vast, symbolic, almost sacred. And so he recognized that poetry itself is elusive: it does not simply belong to the poet, nor to the reader, but exists in the mysterious space between them.

Consider the story of William Blake, who wrote not as one inventing but as one who believed he was receiving visions. His poems were filled with angels, prophetic voices, and symbolic fires. To Blake, the mystery of poetry was not an obstacle but its essence—it was the way by which humanity touched the divine. He too questioned his relationship to it, wondering if he was merely the instrument of something greater. His life echoes Heaney’s insight that poetry is never merely craft, but communion with mystery.

Think also of Emily Dickinson, who in her solitude wrote verses that still confound and inspire. Her words are riddled with dashes, ambiguities, and riddles of thought. Even to this day, scholars debate their meanings. And perhaps that is the point: poetry is not meant to be solved like a riddle, but to be lived with like a companion. Dickinson herself seemed to marvel at what her own hand had written, as though she too were asking, “What is my relationship to this?”

O children of tomorrow, learn this: do not expect poetry, or any art, to yield its mysteries easily. Its power lies in its ability to remain just beyond reach, to stir wonder and questioning. If poetry were only clarity, it would be a lecture. But because it holds mystery, it becomes an invitation—drawing the heart deeper, urging the soul toward reflection. The mystery is not a weakness, but the very gift that keeps poetry alive across generations.

Practical wisdom calls you: when you read poetry, do not rush to explain it. Sit with it. Let the mystery surround you, and let its meanings shift as your life changes. When you write, do not demand mastery. Accept that the poem may know more than you do, and that in writing it, you are entering into conversation with something larger than yourself. Be humble before the mystery, and you will discover beauty far beyond the reach of analysis.

Therefore, remember the counsel of Seamus Heaney: “Poetry is always slightly mysterious, and you wonder what is your relationship to it.” Let this wondering be your companion. For mystery is not an obstacle but a path, and your relationship to poetry is not one of ownership but of shared journey. Walk that journey with reverence, and poetry will become not just words on a page, but a mirror of your soul and a guide into the eternal.

––