We have allowed a situation to develop in which it is legal for a

In the chronicles of human morality and governance, few matters strike so deep a chord as the protection of the young. Beeban Kidron’s words, “We have allowed a situation to develop in which it is legal for a multibillion dollar industry to own, wholly and in perpetuity, the intimate and personal details of children,” illuminate a profound modern peril: the commodification of innocence and the abdication of ethical responsibility. Here lies a meditation on privacy, power, and the moral duty of society to safeguard its most vulnerable, a warning that resonates across time, echoing the ancients’ insistence on protecting youth and communal virtue.

From the city-states of Athens to the courts of medieval Europe, laws and customs were often designed to shield children from exploitation and preserve the integrity of their development. Guardians, elders, and magistrates bore the sacred responsibility of defending their welfare, recognizing that the future of the polis rested upon the cultivation of young minds. Kidron’s reflection situates this ancient duty in the modern age, cautioning that legal systems have lagged behind technological innovation, leaving children exposed to the unprecedented reach of corporate power.

History provides a vivid precedent. In 19th-century industrial Britain, child laborers were often exploited in factories, their toil and presence commodified for profit. Reformers such as Lord Shaftesbury fought tirelessly to introduce laws limiting work hours, mandating schooling, and safeguarding health. Kidron’s warning mirrors this lesson for the digital era: just as the state intervened to protect children from industrial exploitation, it must now confront the dominion of corporations over their digital lives.

Consider the modern example of social media platforms and online services collecting vast amounts of data on children. These multibillion-dollar enterprises gather information ranging from behavioral patterns to personal preferences, storing it indefinitely and often using it for profit. Kidron’s words highlight a critical truth: the intimacy of childhood, once private and sacred, has been rendered a legal commodity, controlled by entities accountable to shareholders rather than society or conscience.

The philosophical resonance of her statement is profound. The rights of the child and the responsibility of society are inseparable from the structures of law and commerce. To allow profit motives to supersede protection is to invert the natural order of responsibility, placing power in the hands of those whose interests may conflict with the welfare of the young. The ancients understood that the nurturing of children is foundational to civic stability, ethical culture, and the perpetuation of virtue. Kidron’s reflection echoes this enduring wisdom.

The lesson for contemporary society is urgent and clear. Legal and technological frameworks must evolve to protect children from exploitation, ensure their privacy, and prevent the monopolization of their personal data. Adults, policymakers, and guardians bear the duty of vigilance, crafting laws that align corporate practice with moral obligation, not simply economic expediency. The integrity of childhood depends upon society’s courage to act decisively.

Practically, this teaching calls for engagement, advocacy, and education. Parents and educators should be vigilant about the platforms children use; lawmakers must enact protections that prioritize privacy over profit; and individuals must cultivate awareness of how personal data is gathered and exploited. Collective action and ethical regulation can reclaim the digital realm as a safe space for children to grow, explore, and learn.

Thus, Beeban Kidron’s words resound as a timeless admonition: the exploitation of children, even under the cloak of legality, is a moral crisis demanding response. Let this reflection guide leaders and citizens alike, reminding all that safeguarding youth is both an ethical imperative and a societal investment. In defending their privacy, we preserve innocence, nurture virtue, and secure the future for generations yet unborn.