David Brainerd
David Brainerd – Life, Ministry, and Legacy
Learn about the life, struggles, missionary labors, spiritual insights, and lasting influence of David Brainerd (1718–1747), a devoted American missionary to Native Americans whose diaries shaped the modern missionary movement.
Introduction
David Brainerd was a short-lived but profoundly impactful American Presbyterian missionary and minister. Born on April 20, 1718, and dying on October 9, 1747, he devoted his brief life to the evangelization of Native American peoples, enduring physical suffering, spiritual trials, and isolation along the way. His journals and the biography published by Jonathan Edwards became enduring sources of inspiration for missionaries and Christian readers for generations.
Though he lived only 29 years, Brainerd’s zeal, humility, and commitment left a legacy that influenced mission movements in the centuries that followed.
Early Life and Family
David Brainerd was born in Haddam, Connecticut Colony (part of British America at the time). Hezekiah Brainerd, served in the Connecticut legislature, and his mother was Dorothy Hobart (sometimes recorded Dorothy Mason).
Brainerd experienced early loss: his father died in 1727 when David was about nine, and his mother passed away about five years later, leaving him orphaned as a teenager. Jerusha.
In youth, Brainerd was earnest and introspective, developing a seriousness about spiritual matters.
Youth, Education & Conversion
Education and Struggles at Yale
In 1739, Brainerd entered Yale College to pursue theological studies.
At Yale he was also caught up in the religious tensions of the time (the Great Awakening) and made a controversial remark in private about a tutor having “no more grace than a chair.” That remark eventually led to his expulsion in 1742 for refusing to publicly retract it.
Because colonial Connecticut law required a minister to hold a degree from Yale, Harvard, or European university, Brainerd’s expulsion meant he could not be ordained under those formal rules.
Spiritual Awakening
Though challenged by health, studies, and institutional resistance, Brainerd experienced a deep spiritual conversion. On July 12, 1739, he recorded an experience of “unspeakable glory” and a heartfelt desire to devote himself wholly to God.
From that point onward, he felt a strong calling to Christian ministry, particularly to those who had yet to hear the gospel.
Ministerial & Missionary Work
Licensing and Early Ministry
After his expulsion, Brainerd was licensed to preach (by evangelical “New Light” ministers) in 1742. Society in Scotland for Propagating Christian Knowledge. November 25, 1742, he was approved for such missionary service.
In early 1743, he briefly served a church in Long Island before setting out into the frontier mission field.
Missions Among Native Americans
From 1743 to 1747, Brainerd labored among various Native American tribes, especially among Delaware (Lenape) Indians and others along the Delaware River, in New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania.
-
His earliest assignment was at Kaunameek (a Mohican settlement near present-day Nassau, New York).
-
Later, he ministered among Delaware Indians in the valleys along the Delaware River, including work at Crossweeksung, New Jersey, where a Native congregation grew to over 130 members.
-
He often preached via an interpreter, such as Moses Tunda Tatamy, when working among Native congregations.
Brainerd’s missionary strategy combined itinerant preaching, personal engagement, prayer, evangelistic fervor, and community formation among Native believers.
He also declined offers to settle into established churches, preferring the frontier missionary calling even amid hardship.
Trials, Illness, & Final Years
Physical and Emotional Suffering
Throughout his missionary years Brainerd struggled with chronic tuberculosis (consumption) and frequent physical weakness.
He recorded many seasons of deep spiritual depression, loneliness, and doubt in his diaries, wrestling with discouragement even as he pressed on in ministry.
Conditions in the wilderness were harsh: meager food, isolation, travel through rugged terrain, primitive housing, and limited rest.
In late 1746, his health had deteriorated to the point that he could no longer continue active missionary work.
Final Months and Death
Brainerd traveled to Northampton, Massachusetts to stay in the home of Jonathan Edwards, who had become a friend and supporter. May 28, 1747.
During these final months, he was cared for by Jerusha Edwards (Jonathan Edwards’ daughter), who nursed him faithfully until his death.
On October 9, 1747, Brainerd died at age 29.
Writings, Journal, & Biography
Diaries and Journals
Brainerd kept an extensive diary / journal chronicling his spiritual struggles, missionary labor, theological reflections, and emotional life.
These writings reveal both his deep piety and frequent despair, his dependence on God, and his unrelenting zeal to see the gospel advanced among the Native Americans.
Jonathan Edwards’s Biography
After Brainerd’s death, Jonathan Edwards edited and published the material in 1749 under the title An Account of the Life of the Late Reverend Mr. David Brainerd (commonly known now as The Life and Diary of David Brainerd).
This biography became highly influential in Protestant circles, especially among evangelicals and missionaries.
Impact & Legacy
Influence on Missions & Evangelism
Though Brainerd made relatively few converts during his life, his posthumous influence is vast. William Carey, Henry Martyn, and Jim Elliott.
John Wesley reportedly urged preachers to read Brainerd’s biography carefully because of its spiritual power.
Brainerd’s example contributed to the shaping of the modern missionary movement by illustrating that a life dedicated wholly to God, despite pain and weakness, could bear fruit beyond what was visible in the moment.
Influence in American Higher Education
The controversy around Brainerd’s expulsion from Yale helped stir dissatisfaction among Presbyterians and other evangelical groups, contributing to the founding of new institutions. For instance, the College of New Jersey (later Princeton) was partly born from tensions that included Brainerd’s case.
Also, the model of Christian outreach to Native Americans inspired educational programs for both colonists and indigenous peoples (e.g. the early roots of Dartmouth).
Character, Spirituality & Lessons
Traits & Patterns
-
Wholehearted devotion — Brainerd exemplified a life surrendered to God, often stating that his purpose was not comfort but the salvation of those he served.
-
Perseverance amid suffering — He continued missionary labor even when physically weak, discouraged, and isolated.
-
Transparency about spiritual struggle — His journal does not hide depression, doubts, or emotional anguish; yet he did not abandon faith in those times.
-
Simplicity and austerity — Brainerd embraced a modest lifestyle: simple food, basic housing, long travel, and few personal comforts.
Enduring Lessons
-
God can use weak vessels.
Brainerd’s life shows that physical frailty and inner suffering need not prevent spiritual impact. -
The value of the hidden life.
Much of his work was unseen; yet, over time, it bore fruit in movements and lives far beyond his immediate circle. -
Honesty in faith.
Brainerd modeled openness about spiritual darkness and doubt, which can help others feel less alone in their struggles. -
Sacrificial commitment.
His willingness to forgo comfort to reach those unreached offers a challenge to modern believers about the cost of discipleship.
Selected Quotes & Excerpts
Because much of Brainerd’s writings exist in personal journals, quotes are often brief but piercing. Some of these are:
-
“All my desire was the conversion of the heathen, and all my hope was in God.”
-
“I never, since I began to preach, could feel any freedom to enter into other men’s labours and settle down in the ministry where the gospel was preached before.”
-
“I live in the most lonely, melancholy desert … My diet consists mostly of hasty pudding, boiled corn, and bread baked in the ashes.”
-
In his final times he reflects on deep suffering: “In the greatest distress that ever I endured … which either strangled me or threw me into a straining to vomit.”
These glimpses reflect the depth of his spiritual authenticity, his suffering, and his persistence.
Conclusion
David Brainerd’s life is a powerful testimony: though brief, it carried weight far beyond his years. His missionary zeal, spiritual transparency, and radical surrender helped shape the heart of modern evangelical missions. Through his journal and Edwards’s biography, Brainerd continues to speak to generations about the cost and beauty of following Christ wholeheartedly.