Dorothy Kilgallen
Discover the life of Dorothy Kilgallen (1913–1965) — pioneering columnist, journalist, and TV panelist. From The Voice of Broadway to probing the JFK assassination, explore her legacy, controversies, and quotes.
Introduction
Dorothy Mae Kilgallen was a prominent American journalist, newspaper columnist, radio and television personality, and a fixture on the game show What’s My Line? Her fearless reporting, glamorous public image, and relentless curiosity made her one of mid-20th century America’s most recognizable media figures. Beyond gossip and showbiz, she tackled major criminal trials and the Kennedy assassination—endeavors that left behind a legacy of both admiration and mystery.
Early Life and Family
Dorothy Kilgallen was born on July 3, 1913 in Chicago, Illinois, to James Lawrence Kilgallen, a newspaper reporter, and Mae Ahern Kilgallen.
Her father’s career with the Hearst organization meant the family moved several times; by 1920 they settled in Brooklyn, New York when he worked as a roving correspondent. Erasmus Hall High School in Brooklyn.
She briefly attended The College of New Rochelle, but after two semesters she left to pursue journalism full time.
From a young age, Dorothy displayed ambition and a knack for writing—her father’s profession certainly influenced her.
Youth & Early Career
At around 17 or 18 years old, Dorothy began working as a reporter for the New York Evening Journal, part of the Hearst newspaper chain.
One early claim to fame came in 1936, when Dorothy participated in a contest among three reporters to travel around the world using only ordinary public transportation. She was the only woman in the race and placed second. She later wrote about that experience in her book Girl Around the World.
In November 1938, she launched her syndicated column “The Voice of Broadway”, which blended show business gossip, commentary, and reporting on broader issues. Over time it was syndicated widely—at its height reaching over 140 newspapers.
Her column’s success and personality led Dorothy into radio and later television. In 1945 she and her husband launched a radio show Breakfast With Dorothy and Dick, which ran for many years, mixing chat, interviews, gossip, and commentary.
Career & Achievements
Journalism & Columnist Work
Though known for showbiz, Dorothy did not shy from hard reporting. She covered criminal trials and controversial cases—most famously the Sam Sheppard murder trial (1954), in which she challenged the legitimacy of the verdict and later claimed knowledge that the presiding judge had prejudged the defendant guilty before trial. Her reporting helped lead to the retrial and eventual acquittal of Sheppard.
Later, Dorothy turned to the John F. Kennedy assassination in 1963. She expressed skepticism about the official Warren Commission findings, published Jack Ruby’s previously closed testimony in her column, and asserted that “the whole truth has not been told.”
Her investigative ambition in that arena has fueled speculation for decades about the circumstances surrounding her death.
Television: What’s My Line?
In 1950, Dorothy became one of the original panelists on the game show What’s My Line? She appeared regularly—often every Sunday—until her death in 1965.
Her presence on TV reinforced her image as urbane, witty, well informed, and glamorous.
Other Appearances & Authorship
-
Dorothy made occasional cameo appearances in films, e.g. Sinner Take All (1936) and Fly-Away Baby (1937).
-
She published Girl Around the World in 1936 (about her global race experience).
-
A posthumous book, Murder One, compiled her writings on famous crime cases.
Personal Life
On April 6, 1940, Dorothy married Richard Kollmar, an actor, singer, and Broadway producer.
They cohabited life in New York and ran the radio show from their home.
Historical Context & Challenges
Dorothy’s career spanned a time when journalism was transforming, especially for women. She entered a male-dominated field and forged a space as both gossip columnist and serious investigative journalist. Her crossover into radio and television also reflected the media shifts of mid-century America.
Her willingness to tackle sensitive political cases (e.g. JFK, organized crime) placed her at odds with powerful institutions, elevating both her influence and scrutiny.
Death & Controversy
On November 8, 1965, Dorothy Kilgallen was found dead in her Manhattan townhouse.
Her death came just after a live appearance on What’s My Line? on November 7.
Among the mysterious details:
-
Some of her research files and notes on the JFK case vanished after her death.
-
She had publicly criticized the Warren Commission and published Jack Ruby’s testimony which was originally considered secret.
-
Some believe suppression or pressure may have played a role.
Because of these factors, her death is often called “the mysterious death of Dorothy Kilgallen.”
Legacy & Influence
Dorothy Kilgallen’s legacy is multifaceted:
-
She broke barriers for women in journalism and became one of the most visible female voices of her era.
-
Her blend of gossip, showbiz, and hard news reporting made her work distinct and popular.
-
Her investigative efforts, especially in the Sheppard and JFK cases, have kept her relevant in discussions about journalism, power, and conspiracy.
-
On television, she left a mark as a polished, articulate, and sharp panelist whose presence on What’s My Line? influenced public perceptions of journalists.
Even today, her name appears in books, documentaries, and speculation about the Kennedy assassination—her story continues to captivate.
Personality, Style & Traits
Kilgallen combined glamour with grit. She had a public persona of sophistication—fluent in the vernacular of show business—but underneath was a serious reporter’s tenacity. Colleagues noted that while she was known for gossip columns, her curiosity often led her into deeper investigations.
She could be bold and confrontational, particularly toward those she believed were hiding truths. Her coverage sometimes ran against pressures from newspaper editors or political forces.
She also valued credibility and integrity: for instance, she insisted on taking full responsibility when her newspaper finally published Jack Ruby’s Warren Commission testimony.
Notable Quotes
Dorothy Kilgallen left behind a few memorable lines and writings, notable especially in context:
“The point to be remembered in this historic case is that the whole truth has not been told.”
— From her commentary on the JFK assassination
“That story is not going to die as long as there’s a real reporter alive — and there are a lot of them alive.”
— Her belief in journalism’s duty and continuity in covering the assassination.
These reflect her conviction that journalism should uncover and sustain truth, even amid suppression or danger.
Lessons from Dorothy Kilgallen’s Life
-
Be Versatile in Your Craft
Dorothy didn’t confine herself to gossip or light fare. She ventured from columns to criminal trials to television, demonstrating breadth. -
Courage in Reporting
She pursued sensitive, controversial stories despite risk or institutional resistance. -
Balance Public Presence With Substance
Her glamour and media visibility never fully eclipsed her seriousness as a journalist. -
Legacy Is Built by Questions, Not Always Answers
Though she died under mysterious circumstances, her questions continue to stir discussion and inquiry. -
Truth-Seeking Often Has Costs
Her life underscores that journalistic bravery may invite dangers, suppression, or peril—yet many believe her efforts were worth it.
Conclusion
Dorothy Kilgallen embodied a rare blend of star power and investigative passion. From her column The Voice of Broadway to her long tenure on What’s My Line?, she became a household name. Yet beneath the public façade lay a journalist determined to penetrate secrecy, confront contradictions, and ask the questions others would not.
Her untimely and unresolved death ensures that, in some ways, her story remains open—inviting new generations to revisit her work, her questions, and her quest for truth.
Further reading on Kilgallen’s death and legacy