George Crook
Explore the life of Major General George Crook (1828–1890): his early years, Civil War service, campaigns against Native American tribes, leadership style, and the complex legacy he left behind.
Introduction
George R. Crook (September 8, 1828 – March 21, 1890) was a distinguished U.S. Army officer whose career spanned frontier duty, the Civil War, and numerous Indian Wars.
Early Life and Education
George Crook was born on September 8, 1828, on a farm near Taylorsville, Ohio, to Thomas Crook and Elizabeth Matthews Crook.
Through the influence of Congressman Robert Schenck, Crook was nominated to the United States Military Academy at West Point.
Upon graduation, Crook was commissioned as a brevet second lieutenant and assigned to the 4th U.S. Infantry.
One of his early notable campaigns was the Pitt River Expedition in 1857, during which he was wounded by an arrow in one of the engagements.
Civil War Service
When the American Civil War broke out in 1861, Crook’s frontier service was cut short. He was appointed colonel of the 36th Ohio Volunteer Infantry on September 12, 1861, and sent to western Virginia.
-
On September 7, 1862, Crook was promoted to brigadier general and led a brigade from Ohio in the Maryland Campaign, participating in the Battles of South Mountain and Antietam.
-
He later commanded a cavalry division in the Army of the Cumberland and saw action in the Chickamauga campaign.
-
In 1864, Crook was sent back east, participating in Grant’s campaigns: he led forces at Cloyd’s Mountain, fought in the Shenandoah Valley (Third Winchester, Fisher’s Hill, Cedar Creek), and assumed command of the Department of West Virginia.
-
In February 1865, he was captured by Confederate raiders at Cumberland, Maryland, and held as a prisoner until exchanged about a month later.
-
In the final Appomattox campaign, Crook commanded a cavalry division and engaged in battles such as Five Forks, Sayler’s Creek, and was present at the surrender at Appomattox Court House.
After the war, he received a brevet promotion to major general in the regular army but reverted to his permanent rank, later being promoted to lieutenant colonel.
Frontier Duty and Indian Wars
Following the Civil War, Crook was assigned to frontier commands in the Pacific Northwest and the West. His campaigns against Native American tribes would come to define much of his later career.
Key Campaigns & Tactics
-
Snake War (1864–68): Crook directed winter campaigns in Oregon and the Great Basin, using tactics like surprise attacks and leveraging scouts, catching tribes off guard in their winter camps.
-
Yavapai / Apache Wars: In Arizona Territory, Crook used Apache scouts and reorganization of his forces to press the Apache onto reservations. He won battles such as Salt River Canyon and Turret Peak.
-
Department of the Platte & Sioux Campaigns: In the mid-1870s, Crook commanded the Department of the Platte and took part in the 1876 Rosebud Expedition. At the Battle of Rosebud, Crook’s forces were engaged by Lakota and Cheyenne warriors under Crazy Horse and ultimately withdrew.
-
Geronimo Campaign (1886): Perhaps Crook’s most famous mission was in Arizona/Mexico against Chiricahua Apaches under Geronimo. He negotiated a surrender in March 1886, only to see Geronimo and some followers escape at night. The campaign ended when Crook was replaced by Nelson A. Miles.
Notably, Crook sometimes advocated for better treatment of Native Americans, criticising abuses such as the unjust imprisonment of Apache scouts who had served the U.S. Army.
Leadership, Character & Reputation
George Crook’s style and reputation were marked by a blend of toughness, tactical acumen, and a degree of moral concern:
-
He was respected by many Native American leaders. After his death, Oglala Lakota chief Red Cloud said: “He, at least, never lied to us. His words gave us hope.”
-
His contemporaries sometimes called him “the best of the Indian fighters and managers.”
-
Still, his record is not free from controversy. While more humane than many of his era, he operated within the framework of U.S. expansionist policy and forceful relocation of indigenous peoples.
-
In his later years, Crook increasingly spoke out against certain injustices in Indian policy, a tilt toward humanitarian concern beyond purely military goals.
-
His strategies on the frontier—use of scouts, surprise winter operations, blending conventional and irregular tactics—were innovative for his time.
-
Thomas E. Sheridan and other historians have noted that Crook’s own respect for indigenous cultures sometimes put him at odds with Washington’s harsher policies.
Final Years and Death
Crook’s last assignments included command of the Military Division of the Missouri, headquartered in Chicago. March 21, 1890, in Chicago, Illinois.
Originally buried in Oakland, Maryland, Crook’s remains were later reinterred in Arlington National Cemetery on November 11, 1890.
After his death, his legacy was memorialized in place names (e.g. Crook County in Oregon and Wyoming), and military honors.
Legacy and Impact
George Crook’s legacy is multifaceted and debated:
Positive aspects:
-
He blended operational competence with a level of moral concern rare in many contemporaries.
-
He introduced flexible, frontier-adapted tactics using scouts and surprise operations.
-
His willingness to challenge mistreatment of Native allies (e.g. Apache scouts) give him a somewhat more just reputation than many Indian War commanders.
-
He is remembered in U.S. military history as a model of perseverance and adaptation across eras.
Critiques and complexities:
-
Despite his more moderate stance, Crook was still a participant in campaigns that dispossessed Native American tribes and enforced federal Indian policy through force.
-
Not all his campaigns succeeded—his retreat at Rosebud is sometimes viewed as missed opportunity, and his failure to permanently end Geronimo’s resistance led to his replacement.
-
Some historians argue that his humanitarian impulses were limited and outweighed by his military obligations and constraints.
Memorable Statements & Reflections
Although few direct personal quotes survive, some attributed lines and recorded assessments offer insight:
“All the tribes tell the same story. They are surrounded on all sides; the game is destroyed or driven away; they are left to starve, and there remains but one thing for them to do – fight while they can.”
— attributed to General George Crook in his reflections on Native American struggles
Also, his reputation among Native Americans is summarized in Red Cloud’s remark:
“He, at least, never lied to us. His words gave us hope.”
Additionally, his friends and peers recalled him as both soldier and humanitarian—Rutherford B. Hayes said Crook “wears the double wreath — the soldier’s and the humanitarian’s.”
Lessons from George Crook’s Life
-
Adaptability in changing warfare
Crook’s transition from frontier operations to large-scale Civil War campaigns and back to irregular frontier warfare demonstrates the importance of flexibility in military leadership. -
Moral limits in military service
His attempts to balance force with fairness remind us that military leaders face ethical constraints even when obeying orders. -
Respect can forge credibility
His rapport with some Native American groups, and reputation for honesty, gave him influence beyond mere intimidation. -
Complex legacies endure
A figure can be both a warrior and critic; Crook’s life illustrates how leaders may evolve in response to policy injustice. -
Tactical innovation matters
His use of scouts, winter operations, and cross-terrain experience offers enduring lessons in asymmetric warfare and frontier strategy.
Conclusion
Major General George Crook stands as one of the more intriguing figures of 19th-century U.S. military history. He bridged eras—the frontier, civil strife, and the Indian Wars—and left a legacy tinged by both military success and moral questioning. His willingness to challenge abuses while serving as an instrument of policy makes him a complex subject of those who study American expansion, military ethics, and frontier history.