John Mason Brown
A complete biography of John Mason Brown (1900–1969), the influential American drama critic and author. Explore his early life, career, style, key works, and lasting impact on theater criticism.
Introduction
John Mason Brown (July 3, 1900 – March 16, 1969) was one of the most prominent American drama critics of the mid-20th century. His trenchant, witty, and erudite columns and essays helped shape public discourse about American and European theater during a period of tremendous change in dramatic art. Over decades, his voice was a bridge between the stage and the reading public, helping theater lovers interpret, critique, and understand dramatic works. His legacy extends to criticism as a literary art and to the standards he helped set in theatrical evaluation.
Early Life and Family
John Mason Brown was born on July 3, 1900 in Louisville, Kentucky. John Mason Brown Sr., a lawyer, and Caroline Carroll Ferguson.
Brown’s family heritage was notable: he traced descent from early colonial families, and his grandfather, also named John Mason Brown (1837–1890), served in the Union Army during the American Civil War.
Youth and Education
Brown showed early interest in literature and drama. He attended Harvard University, graduating in 1923.
After college, Brown traveled in Europe to survey theatrical styles and traditions, deepening his appreciation and critical perspective.
Career and Achievements
Early Criticism & Journalism
Brown began gaining recognition in the mid-1920s. In 1925, he became a theater critic for Theatre Arts magazine. 1929, he joined the New York Evening Post as drama critic, where he remained until 1941. World-Telegram.
War Service and Return to Criticism
During World War II, Brown served in the United States Navy, beginning in 1942. Ancon and was involved in Operation Husky (the invasion of Sicily). To All Hands.
After the war, in 1944, Brown started writing his long-running column “Seeing Things” for The Saturday Review, which he continued until his death in 1969.
Public Profile & Influence
Brown was also a public figure on radio and television. He appeared as a permanent panelist on the CBS show The Last Word, which won a Peabody Award in 1957.
In 1963, he famously resigned from the Pulitzer Prize drama jury when the advisory board declined to award Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? by Edward Albee, a play he and another juror had supported.
Brown also held roles beyond criticism. He was a trustee of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and a judge for the Book-of-the-Month Club.
Historical Milestones & Context
-
Brown’s career spanned the Golden Age of American theater, with the rise of Broadway, the maturation of American playwrights (O’Neill, Miller, Albee), and increasing attention to dramatic realism and experimentation.
-
He bridged eras—from the 1920s modernists to the postwar avant-garde—and his criticism responded to evolving forms, such as theater of the absurd, social realism, and emerging trends in dramatic structure.
-
His wartime service gave him a direct experience of global upheaval, which colored his sensibilities and lent gravity to his later reflections.
-
His resignation from the Pulitzer jury marked a moment of principle, reflecting the tensions between critics, institutions, and the evolving tastes of theater.
Legacy and Influence
John Mason Brown is remembered not just as a critic, but as a literary critic of theater, one who held that criticism itself could be art.
-
His Seeing Things columns are valued as a long-running chronicle of American dramatic culture.
-
His style combined sharp insight, wit, historical knowledge, and accessible literary flair, influencing later critics seeking balance between polemic and artistry.
-
He was inducted posthumously into the American Theatre Hall of Fame in 1981.
Though less widely read today, scholars and enthusiasts of theater critical history view him as a bridge between popular criticism and scholarly discourse.
Personality and Talents
Brown was known for his wit, erudition, and sharp intellectual standards. His writing was never dull: he could be witty, sardonic, lyrical, and moral all in the same paragraph.
He had a deep grounding in theater history and criticism; his familiarity with classical drama, European traditions, and the evolving styles of contemporary theater gave his reviews depth.
He was also energetic in his public engagement—radio, television, lectures—bridging the divide between specialist critic and general audience.
Famous Quotes of John Mason Brown
Some of Brown’s more enduring quotations include:
“Some television programs are so much chewing gum for the eyes.”
“The only true happiness comes from squandering ourselves for a purpose.”
“So often we rob tomorrow’s memories by today’s economies.”
“Charm is a glow within a woman that casts a most becoming light on others.”
“I, John Brown, am now quite certain that the crimes of this guilty land will never be purged but with Blood.”
These reflect Brown’s mix of social critique, aesthetic observation, and poetic sensibility.
Lessons from John Mason Brown
-
Criticism as creative act
Brown treated critical writing not as mere judgment but as literary expression—with voice, style, and moral engagement. -
Know your tradition
His depth of historical and theatrical knowledge gave weight to his evaluations. -
Engage, don’t alienate
He balanced insider discourse and broad readability, making theater criticism accessible without losing rigor. -
Integrity over compromise
His resignation from the Pulitzer jury underscores that principles matter, even amid institutional constraints. -
Bridge art and life
His wartime experiences, civic roles, and public presence show that a critic is not a detached spectator but often a participant in cultural life.
Conclusion
John Mason Brown remains a towering figure in the history of American theater criticism. His voice spoke to both stage and audience, combining intellect, moral seriousness, and literary flair. Though decades have passed since his death, his writings continue to offer insight—into how we judge drama, how we place it within culture, and how we confront the evolving human condition through the theater.