Lucius Quintus Cincinnatus Lamar II
Learn about Lucius Q. C. Lamar II (1825–1893), a Confederate soldier turned U.S. statesman, Secretary of the Interior, and Supreme Court justice. Explore his life, political path, philosophies, and controversies.
Introduction
Lucius Quintus Cincinnatus Lamar II (September 17, 1825 – January 23, 1893) was an American politician, diplomat, jurist, and former Confederate officer whose life spanned the upheaval of the Civil War, Reconstruction, and the postwar era of reconciliation. He served in both chambers of Congress for Mississippi, was Secretary of the Interior under President Grover Cleveland, and was appointed an Associate Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court. Lamar’s trajectory—from pro-secession advocate to a “bridge” figure in national politics—makes his story a complex reflection of 19th-century American tensions.
This article traces his early life, political evolution, major roles, controversies, and lasting impact—illuminating both his achievements and the contradictions of his era.
Early Life and Family
Lamar was born near Eatonton, Putnam County, Georgia, on September 17, 1825, to Lucius Quintus Cincinnatus Lamar I and Sarah Bird.
Tragedy visited early: Lamar’s father, a lawyer and judge, died by suicide when young Lamar was nine years old — a loss that affected the family’s finances and emotional life.
His family had several prominent connections: for example, his uncle Mirabeau B. Lamar was the second president of the Republic of Texas.
In his youth, Lamar was schooled in Georgia (Milledgeville, Baldwin and Newton Counties) and in a manual labor school in Covington. Emory College in Oxford, Georgia, graduating in 1845.
While at Emory, he engaged in campus debate and built the intellectual foundation for his legal and political career.
Youth, Education, and Early Legal Career
After graduating, Lamar read law in Macon, Georgia, and was admitted to the Georgia bar in 1847. Oxford, Mississippi, where he established a legal practice and, for a year, served as professor of mathematics at the University of Mississippi.
He then returned to Georgia briefly, serving in the Georgia House of Representatives (1853–1854) before returning to Mississippi in 1855 to resume his legal and political work.
During his early legal and political life, Lamar embraced proslavery and states’ rights positions—stances that would define much of his antebellum and wartime alignment.
Political Career Before the Civil War
In 1857, Lamar was elected to the U.S. House of Representatives for Mississippi’s 1st District, serving until January 1861.
As tensions escalated after the 1860 election of Abraham Lincoln, Lamar resigned from Congress (December 1860) and participated in Mississippi’s secession convention, drafting the state’s Ordinance of Secession on January 9, 1861.
Civil War and Confederacy Involvement
During the Civil War, Lamar joined the Confederate cause. He raised the 19th Mississippi Infantry Regiment, initially serving as lieutenant colonel and later colonel after an early battle in which his commanding officer was killed.
In 1862, he was appointed as Special Confederate Commissioner to Russia and later worked diplomatically in Europe (France, England), though his efforts to secure recognition for the Confederacy were unsuccessful.
Towards the war’s end, Lamar served as aide to General James Longstreet and acted in judicial capacities within the Confederate administration.
Reconstruction & Return to National Politics
After the war, Lamar returned to Oxford, Mississippi. With the abolition of slavery, his prior wealth and land holdings were disrupted.
He resumed teaching and law: from 1866, he taught metaphysics, social science, and law at the University of Mississippi.
In 1873, he was elected to the U.S. House again, becoming the first Democrat from Mississippi to hold a House seat since the Civil War.
In Congress, Lamar earned a reputation for moderation and conciliation—some called him “the Great Pacificator” for efforts to heal sectional divides.
Cabinet & Supreme Court
Secretary of the Interior
President Grover Cleveland selected Lamar as Secretary of the Interior in March 1885.
Associate Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court
In December 1887, Cleveland nominated Lamar to fill the Supreme Court vacancy left by Justice William Woods.
He was the first Southern nominee to the Court since the Civil War—a symbolic move toward sectional reconciliation. around 96 opinions, issued 13 dissents, and was regarded as relatively moderate in approach.
Lamar served on the Court until his death on January 23, 1893, in Vineville, Georgia.
Personality, Philosophy & Controversies
Lamar embodied the contradictions of his epoch. On one hand, he was a unifying figure, bridging sectional divides via moderation and oratory. On the other, he remained deeply aligned with—and defended—the antebellum social order and white supremacy.
His eloquence, legal acumen, and ability to navigate shifting political terrains gave him influence beyond many peers.
But criticisms forever shadow him:
-
His active secessionism and role in drafting Mississippi’s secession ordinance marked him as deeply committed to the Confederacy.
-
His opposition to Reconstruction policies and Black political participation reflect the racial prejudices that underpinned much of postwar Southern politics.
-
Some contemporaries and later critics considered his Supreme Court jurisprudence undistinguished—competent but lacking boldness.
One notable moment of moral courage in his career was his eulogy for Senator Charles Sumner (a Republican abolitionist), delivered by Lamar in 1874. It was a gesture that, despite his own politics, recognized dignified statesmanship beyond party lines. This act was later honored in John F. Kennedy’s Profiles in Courage.
Legacy and Influence
Lamar’s legacy is contested and multifaceted:
-
Symbols of reconciliation: His appointment to the Supreme Court and moderation in Congress were viewed as signs of national healing after Reconstruction.
-
Place names: Counties (in Alabama, Georgia, Mississippi), roads, and towns bear his name; in Yellowstone National Park, the Lamar River and Lamar Valley honor his role as Secretary of the Interior.
-
Memorializations reexamined: In recent years, institutions have reconsidered commemorations of Lamar due to his pro-Confederate stance and views on race. For example, Emory University removed his name from endowed professorships after review.
-
Historical interest: He remains a figure of study in the contexts of Reconstruction, jurisprudence, Southern history, and the politics of reconciliation.
Famous Quotes
While Lamar is less known for quotable aphorisms than for his oratorical style in speeches and public addresses, here is one that reflects his posture toward national unity:
“Peace will come, but it must be founded on justice, not force.”
— paraphrase attributed in his reconciliation rhetoric (often cited in works on Lamar’s rhetoric)
Another reflection attributed in historical accounts, reflecting his sense of Southern identity:
“This beloved country of ours … will be a country to live for, to pray for, to fight for, and if necessary, to die for.”
— as spoken early in his Confederate service.
Due to the nature of 19th-century speeches and the conventions of record-keeping, many of his speeches survive more in fragments and tone than polished quotations.
Lessons from Lamar’s Life
-
Transition through tumultuous eras
Lamar’s career spans antebellum America, the Civil War, Reconstruction, and the Gilded Age—offering a lens on how statesmen adapt (or don’t) across crises. -
The complexity of reconciliation
Lamar’s role as a “bridge” figure shows that reconciliation often requires compromises that leave wounds unhealed. -
Moral contradictions in public life
His life underscores how personal convictions—especially about race and rights—shape legacies, even as political pragmatism and compromise are praised. -
Power of rhetoric and moderation
His moderation and eloquence granted him influence even when the tides of politics were polarized. -
Reassessment over time
Modern perspectives show how societal values shift: what was once honored (e.g. honoring Lamar) is now subject to critical review. His life reminds us that history is not static; reputations evolve.
Conclusion
Lucius Q. C. Lamar II remains a compelling, controversial figure. He was a man of his time—one who championed the Southern cause, navigated the consequences of defeat, and sought to carve a role for himself in a redefined Union. His service in Congress, the Cabinet, and the Supreme Court place him among a select group of 19th-century American statesmen. Yet his record is inseparable from the racial and regional ideologies of his era.