Salvatore J. Cordileone
Salvatore J. Cordileone – Life, Ministry, and Influence
Explore the life of Archbishop Salvatore J. Cordileone: his early years, theological formation, ecclesiastical career, public positions, and the controversies and legacy of a prominent American Catholic leader.
Introduction
Salvatore Joseph Cordileone (born June 5, 1956) is an American Roman Catholic prelate who currently serves as the Archbishop of San Francisco in California.
Known for his conservative theological orientation, his strong stances on issues such as abortion, same-sex marriage, and the Eucharist, and his support for the Extraordinary Form of the Mass, Cordileone has often been a figure of both influence and controversy within U.S. Catholicism.
This article delves into his life, ministry, viewpoints, and legacy.
Early Life and Family
Salvatore Cordileone was born on June 5, 1956, in San Diego, California, to Leon and Mary Cordileone. third of four children in his family.
His grandparents on both sides were Sicilian immigrants. His paternal grandfather worked as a fisherman; his maternal grandfather was a farmer.
Cordileone attended Crawford High School in San Diego, graduating in 1974.
He initially studied at San Diego State University for a year before transferring to the University of San Diego, where he earned a Bachelor of Arts in Philosophy in 1978.
After his undergraduate studies, he went to Rome to study theology at the Pontifical Gregorian University, receiving a Bachelor of Sacred Theology in 1981.
Priesthood and Canonical Formation
Cordileone was ordained a Catholic priest on July 9, 1982, for the Diocese of San Diego by Bishop Leo Thomas Maher.
His first assignment was as associate pastor at St. Martin of Tours Parish in La Mesa, California, from 1982 to 1985.
He returned to Rome to study canon law at the Gregorian, obtaining a Doctorate in Canon Law in 1989.
Upon his return, he served in a variety of roles in the Diocese of San Diego:
-
Priest-secretary to Bishop Robert Brom
-
Tribunal judge and adjutant judicial vicar
-
Pastor of Our Lady of Guadalupe Parish in Calexico (1991–1995)
From 1995 to 2002, he worked in Rome at the Apostolic Signatura (the highest judicial body in the Vatican). Chaplain of His Holiness (Monsignor).
Episcopal and Archiepiscopal Career
Auxiliary Bishop of San Diego (2002–2009)
On July 5, 2002, Pope John Paul II appointed Cordileone as Auxiliary Bishop of San Diego and assigned him the titular see of Natchesium. August 21, 2002, with Robert Brom as principal consecrator, joined by Bishops Raymond Burke and Gilbert Espinosa Chávez.
During his time in San Diego, Cordileone became involved in national U.S. Catholic discussions. In 2006, he proposed (unsuccessfully) that artificial contraception be labeled a grave matter for reception of Communion during a U.S. bishops’ meeting—a move that was debated but not included in the final text.
Bishop of Oakland (2009–2012)
On March 23, 2009, Cordileone was named Bishop of Oakland, succeeding Bishop Allen Vigneron. Cathedral of Christ the Light.
Early in his episcopate at Oakland, Cordileone celebrated a Pontifical High Mass in the Tridentine (Latin, Extraordinary) form, one of the first in Northern California since the liturgical changes after Vatican II.
He also became chair of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) Ad Hoc Committee for the Defense of Marriage, advocating against legalization of same-sex marriage.
Archbishop of San Francisco (2012–Present)
On July 27, 2012, Pope Benedict XVI appointed Cordileone as Archbishop of San Francisco, succeeding Archbishop George Niederauer. October 4, 2012.
Shortly before his installation, in August 2012, Cordileone was arrested after being found over the legal blood alcohol limit in San Diego. reckless driving and was sentenced to probation, fined, and required to attend a victim impact program.
As archbishop, Cordileone has often affirmed the Extraordinary Form of the Mass, encouraging its use in the archdiocese.
He has served in leadership roles within the USCCB. In November 2018, he was selected chair of the Committee on Laity, Marriage, Family Life, and Youth.
Theological Orientation & Public Positions
Cordileone is widely considered a traditionalist and conservative theologian.
Abortion & the Eucharist
He has strongly affirmed that a public Catholic politician who supports abortion rights may be denied Holy Communion in his archdiocese, unless they repudiate that position.
He also argues for providing comprehensive material and spiritual support to pregnant women, emphasizing accompaniment rather than punishment.
Same-Sex Marriage & Sexual Morality
Cordileone was involved in drafting Proposition 8 (California’s 2008 ballot measure defining marriage as the union of a man and a woman) and contributed funds toward its passage.
Within Catholic education, he has at times required teachers in archdiocesan high schools to live in a manner consistent with Catholic doctrine, triggering protests from local lawmakers.
Vaccination & COVID-19
During the COVID-19 pandemic, Cordileone encouraged Catholics to receive vaccination—but he himself disclosed that he had not been vaccinated, telling a newspaper that his physician advised it may not be necessary for him given his health.
Controversies & Public Reactions
Because of his outspoken positions, Cordileone has been a polarizing figure. Some controversies and reactions include:
-
Strong backlash from Catholic faithful, donors, and lay groups following his enforcement of morality clauses and his stance on Communion for Catholic politicians.
-
Public protest in 2015: more than 100 Bay Area Catholics purchased a full-page ad in the San Francisco Chronicle urging Pope Francis to remove Cordileone, citing his harsh language toward LGBTQ individuals.
-
Criticism from secular political leaders over his attempts to regulate moral behavior of school faculty and his positions on public issues.
Still, he retains support among conservative Catholics and those who see him as a clarifying voice in a pluralistic society.
Personality and Leadership Style
While public data is less about personality, several traits and tendencies emerge:
-
Firmness of conviction: Cordileone is known for holding strong doctrinal positions and defending them publicly.
-
Liturgical sensibility: He values the Extraordinary Form of the Mass and traditional liturgical expressions.
-
Judicial and canonical acumen: His doctoral background in canon law and service at the Apostolic Signatura suggest a precision in legal and doctrinal thinking.
-
Willingness to engage publicly: Unlike many bishops who avoid controversy, Cordileone often speaks to media, prints pastoral letters, and enters public debates.
Famous Quotes of Salvatore J. Cordileone
Here are a few notable statements attributed to Archbishop Cordileone:
“A Catholic legislator who supported procured abortion, after knowing the teaching of the Church, commits a manifestly grave sin which is a cause of most serious scandal to others.”
“Every child in the mother’s womb should be welcomed with open arms in our society.”
“Only one idea of marriage can stand … If that’s going to be considered bigoted, we’re going to see our rights being taken away.” (on opposition to same-sex marriage)
“It is important to know that the overwhelming majority of the alleged abuse occurred in the 1960s and ’70s … We believe the bankruptcy process is the best way to provide a compassionate and equitable solution.” (on the Archdiocese’s bankruptcy filing)
Lessons from Salvatore J. Cordileone
From Cordileone’s life and ministry, several lessons may be drawn (for clergy, laity, or observers):
-
Formation matters
His rigorous theological and canonical education underpins his capacity to engage complex ecclesial, legal, and doctrinal issues. -
Courage in polarizing times
He shows that religious leaders sometimes must take unpopular positions to maintain continuity with tradition—but must also accept criticism. -
Balance of public and pastoral roles
Being an archbishop today means interacting in media, politics, and legal arenas while still shepherding spiritual life. -
Accountability and humility
His DUI incident demonstrates how a leader must own mistakes, apologize, and seek reconciliation publicly. -
Continuity with tradition, yet navigating change
His championing of the traditional Mass shows continuity, even as he must lead a diverse, modern archdiocese.
Conclusion
Salvatore J. Cordileone is among the more consequential and controversial Catholic leaders in contemporary America. From his Sicilian immigrant roots in San Diego, through rigorous formation in theology and canon law, to leadership roles in San Diego, Oakland, and now San Francisco, he has remained consistent in theological convictions and public witness.
Whether one agrees or disagrees with his stances, his life illustrates how modern ecclesiastical leadership intersects faith, law, public life, and pluralism. His advocacy for liturgical tradition, clarity on moral teaching, and willingness to engage in public controversies ensure he will remain a subject of study, debate, and significance in the American Church.