There's a certain elitism that has crept into the attitudes of

Host: The rain had just stopped over Washington D.C., leaving the streets gleaming under amber streetlights. Inside a small newsroom café, the faint hum of old television sets mingled with the clatter of cups and the distant rumble of late-night traffic. The air smelled of coffee, ink, and a subtle tension — the kind that lingers after a broadcast ends but the truth still trembles between the lines.

Jack sat by the window, his coat draped over the chair, eyes fixed on a small American flag pin resting beside his espresso. Jeeny entered quietly, her hair damp from the rain, her hands clutching a folder marked “orial Ethics.”

The clock ticked. The neon sign flickered outside. The city breathed in muted rhythm.

Jeeny: “You still wear it, don’t you? The pin.”

Jack: (smirking) “It’s just metal, Jeeny. But apparently, it’s become the national measure of loyalty.”

Host: The words carried a faint mockery, but beneath it, there was fatigue — the kind that comes from arguing too long about things that should be simple.

Jeeny: “It’s not about the metal, Jack. It’s about what it represents. The flag is a symbol — a reminder of shared belief. Of sacrifice.”

Jack: “Or a prop. Depends on who’s wearing it.”

Host: Jeeny’s brow furrowed. Her eyes, usually soft, now held a spark of indignation.

Jeeny: “You think patriotism is a prop?”

Jack: “No. I think performing patriotism is. The moment someone needs to advertise their love for their country with a lapel pin, something’s gone wrong. It’s like trying to prove honesty by swearing louder.”

Host: Outside, a taxi splashed through a puddle, its headlights cutting across their faces, dividing light and shadow like an unseen argument between them.

Jeeny: “That’s exactly what Brit Hume meant when he said there’s a certain elitism creeping into journalism. Some people in the media — maybe like you — sneer at the symbols that matter to the ordinary people.”

Jack: (leans forward) “Elitism? No, Jeeny. It’s not elitist to question a symbol. It’s responsible. When a reporter wears a flag pin, whose truth are they pledging to? The state’s or the people’s?”

Jeeny: “Both. Ideally, both. That’s what the flag stands for — a unity of freedom and accountability. You can’t separate them.”

Host: A brief silence filled the space, heavy and electric. The coffee machine hissed, punctuating the pause like a distant storm.

Jack: “History’s full of flags waving over truths buried deep. Remember 2003? The Iraq War? Every anchor on every major network had that same pin on. They told us it meant solidarity — but it became a shield. They stopped asking questions.”

Jeeny: (quietly) “They were afraid. The country was grieving.”

Jack: “Grieving doesn’t excuse blindness. The press isn’t there to comfort; it’s there to confront.”

Host: Jeeny’s hands trembled slightly as she set her folder down. The pages within rustled, filled with headlines, op-eds, and images of journalists wearing their pins like armor.

Jeeny: “And yet, when they don’t wear it — they’re called traitors. Remember after 9/11, when journalists who didn’t wear the pin were accused of being un-American? That’s not about performance, Jack. That’s about identity — about people needing to see that their voice still matters in the storm.”

Jack: “Or needing to see a reflection that makes them feel safe, even when it’s not true.”

Host: His voice lowered, the kind that presses against the heart instead of shouting over it. The lights flickered, the café now half in shadow, as if even the universe held its breath.

Jeeny: “So what’s your point, Jack? That journalists should strip away all symbols, all emotion, and just report like machines?”

Jack: “I’m saying they should strip away pretense. Truth doesn’t need a costume.”

Jeeny: “Truth always wears a face. That’s how people recognize it.”

Host: The wind outside howled faintly, rattling the windowpanes. A few newspapers blew past on the sidewalk, headlines blurring into streaks of ink and rain.

Jack: “You sound like one of those professors who think symbols heal nations.”

Jeeny: “And you sound like a man who forgot how symbols give meaning to facts.”

Jack: “Facts don’t need meaning. They just need to be true.”

Jeeny: “And truth without meaning is just a cold equation, Jack. That’s what makes journalism human — it connects truth to feeling.”

Host: Their voices clashed — not in volume, but in conviction. The air between them felt like a wire, taut with current.

Jack: “You think wearing that pin connects truth to feeling? It just connects careers to approval ratings.”

Jeeny: “Maybe. But sometimes approval isn’t about ego — it’s about trust. A journalist wearing that flag isn’t saying, ‘I agree with the government.’ They’re saying, ‘I belong to you, the people. I bleed the same.’”

Host: Jack’s jaw tightened. He looked away, toward the window, where the reflection of the flag from the TV news studio across the street fluttered faintly in the glass.

Jack: “Belonging’s dangerous when it blurs the line between truth and tribe.”

Jeeny: “And detachment is dangerous when it turns truth into a weapon instead of a bridge.”

Host: The rain began again — soft this time, like a whispered confession. The world outside blurred, and the glow of the neon sign seemed gentler.

Jeeny: “You know what elitism really is, Jack? It’s not wearing a pin or not wearing one. It’s believing your view of truth is purer than everyone else’s.”

Jack: (pauses) “Maybe. Or maybe elitism is pretending that symbols can replace the hard work of understanding.”

Jeeny: “Understanding doesn’t come from rejection. It comes from empathy — from acknowledging that people feel before they think.”

Host: The tension softened. Jack ran a hand through his hair, his eyes weary, almost haunted.

Jack: “You ever wonder, Jeeny, what we’d talk about if the flag meant the same thing to everyone?”

Jeeny: “Maybe we’d stop talking entirely. Maybe it’s the disagreement that keeps the country alive.”

Host: A faint smile crossed her lips — not of victory, but of acceptance. Jack looked at the small pin again. The metal caught the light, a dull shimmer like an old memory.

Jack: “I’ll give you this — it’s strange how something so small can start a war of ideas.”

Jeeny: “Or end one. Depends who’s listening.”

Host: Outside, the rain eased, leaving behind a thin mist that rose like steam from the streets. The flag reflection wavered in the window, trembling between clarity and blur — neither wholly real nor wholly illusion.

Jack: “Maybe that’s what journalism really is — not the truth itself, but the struggle to keep it visible in the fog.”

Jeeny: “And maybe that’s what patriotism is — not the symbol, but the effort to keep believing it can mean something honest.”

Host: The clock struck midnight. The television screens dimmed, their voices fading into static. Jack reached for the pin, turned it between his fingers, then set it back on the table — not as rejection, but as respect.

Jeeny watched him quietly, her eyes soft, her voice barely above a whisper.

Jeeny: “Maybe we’ve both been right, just from different corners of the same flag.”

Host: The neon sign flickered once, then steadied. The rain stopped completely. And in that fragile quiet, the city, the symbols, and the souls within it all seemed to breathe the same truth — that meaning is never in the metal, but in the mind that dares to question it, and the heart that dares to defend it.